RE: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)

Subject: RE: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)
From: "Gillespie, Stephen (Contractor)" <Stephen -dot- Gillespie -at- Persnet -dot- Navy -dot- Mil>
To: "TECHWR-L" <techwr-l -at- lists -dot- raycomm -dot- com>
Date: Mon, 5 May 2003 16:10:12 -0400

Mark Barker responds to Steve's post on copyrights, plagerism (sic), etc.:

OK, Mark, I agree in concept on your definitions, but I disgree that the
three terms - copyright, plagiarism, & citation (of sources) are separate
issues. For example, by plagiarizing, one is/may be also committing
copyright violation (definitely a crime); similarly, if by using presenting
the words and/or ideas of others, but NOT properly giving credit for the
source through any manner of citation (which, BTW, are not just "academic"
standard), that's also plagiarism (by definition), which can also be the
crime of copyright enfringement. So these three are inextricably bound
together - don't you agree?

Steve Gillespie

-----Original Message-----
From: Mark Baker [mailto:mbaker -at- ca -dot- stilo -dot- com]
Sent: Monday, May 05, 2003 1:55 PM
Subject: Re: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)


You appear to be confusing three different issues:

* Copyright
* Plagerism
* Citation of sources

* Copyright protects the expression of information. That is, it protects the
particular form of words you use to express an idea or a piece of
information. It does not protect the idea or the information itself.
Copyright is a matter of law and is binding on everyone. The fair use
provision of the copyright law cover certain exceptions, such as quoting
limited portions of a text for the purpose of commenting on it.

* Plagerism is passing off someone else's ideas as your own. It is an
academic sin, not a crime. It has nothing to do with the form of expression.
It simply says that you must not pass off someone else's idea as your own.
If you hand in a term paper that you copied word for word from a library
book, you are commiting both plagerism (by representing the ideas as your
own) and copyright violation (by copying someone else's words). To avoid the
accusation of plagerism, you must cite the source of the idea. Citing the
source does nothing to avoid the accusation of copyright violation, unless
your use of copyrighted material falls within fair use provisions of the

* Academic standards require the citation of sources for any assetion of
fact that is not common knowledge. This has nothing to do with either
copyright or plagerism, but with the standards of proof required in academic
work. You must make it possible for the person reading your paper to check
any fact that you assert. The limit on this is that you need not cite a
source for facts that are commonly known and accepted in the field you are
working in.

Only copyright is a matter of law. Plagerism and failure to cite are
academic faults that have no force in law and are commonly ignored in
popular and commerical work. In law there is no protection of ideas or of
information, only of the expression of ideas (copyright) and of specific
processes (patent).

The words of a standard are protected by copyright like any other written
work. The copyright holder can state any conditions they choose for the use
of those words.


Order RoboHelp X3 in May and receive a $100 mail-in rebate, PLUS
free RoboScreenCapture and WebHelp Merge Module.

Order RoboHelp today:

ATTENTION FrameMaker Users: Fill-out the following survey
to receive a chance to win a FREE RoboScreenCapture.

FM users only please:

You are currently subscribed to techwr-l as:
archive -at- raycomm -dot- com
To unsubscribe send a blank email to leave-techwr-l-obscured -at- lists -dot- raycomm -dot- com
Send administrative questions to ejray -at- raycomm -dot- com -dot- Visit for more resources and info.


Previous by Author: RE: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)
Next by Author: RE: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)
Previous by Thread: RE: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)
Next by Thread: RE: How Many Trees? (WAS: URGENT: Immediate ethical issue)

What this post helpful? Share it with friends and colleagues:

Sponsored Ads