Re: Technical writing vs. engineering

Subject: Re: Technical writing vs. engineering
From: chuckm -at- MDHOST -dot- CSE -dot- TEK -dot- COM
Date: Fri, 28 Apr 1995 13:39:11 PDT

I'll keep this short.

When I am told that someone who is not a tech writer can do my job as
well as I can, I ask:

If it is true that anyone that speaks english can do my job as well as
me, then by analogy, it must also be true that anyone that can make a mark
on a piece of paper can be an artist.

So, (hypothetically speaking) here is a piece of paper and a pencil.
Draw me a portrait of anyone you like. It must be good enough that
people will pay good money for it and that an art critic would recognize
as art and not dismiss as chicken scratching.

**

The basic point of this being that the ability to use the tools of a
tech writer does not make one a tech writer anymore than the ability
to cut something with a scalpel makes one a surgeon. This isn't a perfect
analogy, but it gets the point across.

Chuck Melikian


Previous by Author: SME vs Tech Writer WRT ISO 9000
Next by Author: Re: Is the list really slow?
Previous by Thread: Re: Technical writing vs. engineering
Next by Thread: HUMOR: Oxymoron


What this post helpful? Share it with friends and colleagues:

Sponsored Ads


Sponsored Ads