Re: Comma splQuote Marks (Was: )

Subject: Re: Comma splQuote Marks (Was: )
From: "Huber, Mike" <Mike -dot- Huber -at- SOFTWARE -dot- ROCKWELL -dot- COM>
Date: Mon, 8 Jan 1996 12:28:50 -0500

In many technical documents, the text between the parenthesis
represents text to be displayed or interpreted by software.
Since the software may require arbitrary (and often
non-grammatical) punctuation, there is a common standard
that puts punctuation of the quoted text inside the marks, and
punctuation of the sentence outside.

In this standard, the sentence
First select "Edit", and then select "Cut".
is correct, and
First select "Edit," and then select "Cut."
is incorrect, unless the software literally shows

In this example, it doesn't make much sense. But consider:
Type "12-AZ,*," and then press the enter key.
Should the operator include that final comma, or not?

It's a bit ugly, but it's not a matter of sloppiness, and often not
a writer's choice.

From: Dot James[SMTP:dot -at- HPOEMB05 -dot- SJ -dot- HP -dot- COM]
Sent: Monday, January 08, 1996 11:08 AM
To: Multiple recipients of list TEC
Subject: Re: Comma splQuote Marks (Was: )

> The sentence

> First select "Edit", and then select "Cut".

>is perfectly okay. I believe that likewise,

As a former English teacher, I do NOT find the above sentence "okay." As

person now forced to dabble in tech editing (as a part of my contract
job of
production word processor), I have run across this use of comma/period
quotation marks. Is this, indeed, characteristic of technical writing?
Or do
the period and comma belong within the quote marks, per formal writing?
for the latter; I hate to think that tech writing is also sloppy

Dot James in San Jose, CA "The secret of happiness is not doing
dot -at- hpoemb05 -dot- sj -dot- hp -dot- com what one likes to do, but in liking
dotjames -at- paladin-usa -dot- com what one has to do." -- Sir James

Previous by Author: Re: Urban.legends.litigation?
Next by Author: Re: Warnings...from the twilight zone (
Previous by Thread: Re: Comma splQuote Marks (Was: )
Next by Thread: Re: Comma splQuote Marks (Was: )

What this post helpful? Share it with friends and colleagues:

Sponsored Ads