TechWhirl (TECHWR-L) is a resource for technical writing and technical communications professionals of all experience levels and in all industries to share their experiences and acquire information.
For two decades, technical communicators have turned to TechWhirl to ask and answer questions about the always-changing world of technical communications, such as tools, skills, career paths, methodologies, and emerging industries. The TechWhirl Archives and magazine, created for, by and about technical writers, offer a wealth of knowledge to everyone with an interest in any aspect of technical communications.
Subject:Re: Book types most favored From:Jim Grey <jimgrey -at- IQUEST -dot- NET> Date:Mon, 30 Sep 1996 08:36:00 EST
Tim Altom (taltom -at- iquest -dot- net) asked about one of my favorite subjects:
>There has developed a split in the field of computer books between the
>"get-started" easy books, like the "Dummies" series, and the full-scale
>"kitchen-sink" books like the "Unleashed" series. I think I know why people
>would buy each type, and under what conditions, but I wanted to ask the list
>In my case, I usually try to buy a simplified book first, one that's written
>friendly and folksy. That gets me off the ground, after which I usually feel
>the need for a book that has everything in it, just for reference.
>Are others of the same mind, or do you buy one or the other?
I have _Modems For Dummies_ and the authoritative _The Official Hayes Modem
Companion_ on my shelf. When I have modem woes (and who doesn't, from time
to time?), I go to _Modems For Dummies_ first. It is better organized than
_Companion_, and because it is not exhaustive, I find answers in it more
readily. _Companion_ is exhaustive -- it tells me far more than I want to know.
On the other hand, I wouldn't trade my copy of _Windows 95 SECRETS_ for
_Windows 95 For Dummies_. _Windows 95 For Dummies_ is a good book, but it
doesn't have the level of detail I want.
But I'm cheating; I got all of those books for free when I worked for IDG. :)
Because I know what shenanigans go on "in the biz," I always ask around
before I buy a computer book on any subject. Book quality varies wildly,
even within a series. I have some great _Dummies_ books on my shelf. I've
seen some truly awful _Dummies_ books. I've _edited_ some outstanding
books, as well as some horrible books.
Price is also critically important to me. I don't like dropping $40 to $50
on a computer book in the _Unleashed_ or _SECRETS_ size class. I'm much
more willing and likely to spend $20 on a _Dummies_ book. But if a trusted
someone recommends a particular book, I'm likely to buy it regardless of price.
jim grey |beebeebumbleandthestingersmottthehoopleraycharlessingers
jimgrey -at- iquest -dot- net|lonniemackandtwangin'eddiehere'smyringwe'regoingsteadyta
"There. Enough crankiness. Time for more coffee!" - R. Thaler-Carter