TechWhirl (TECHWR-L) is a resource for technical writing and technical communications professionals of all experience levels and in all industries to share their experiences and acquire information.
For two decades, technical communicators have turned to TechWhirl to ask and answer questions about the always-changing world of technical communications, such as tools, skills, career paths, methodologies, and emerging industries. The TechWhirl Archives and magazine, created for, by and about technical writers, offer a wealth of knowledge to everyone with an interest in any aspect of technical communications.
Subject:Re: Agency and interviewing questions From:"Nancy B. Delain" <nbdelain -at- ALBANY -dot- NET> Date:Tue, 10 Dec 1996 07:53:05 -0500
>>Even though I like to look at writing samples, I have been suspicious
of them ever since I saw a woman take all the leftover unclaimed
displays at an STC Publications Competition award banquet several years ago.<<
LOL!! That's a good one! The issue of whether or not a writing sample is
actually authentically that applicant's writing sample never crossed my
mind, but I suppose if someone actually did this it's a viable one.
BTW, I like your response to the writing-sample issue. I'm glad to read
that other people take confidentiality agreements seriously.
Nancy Baum Delain
>Melissa Hunter-Kilmer wrote:
>> The agency does what we ask, but it takes them some time to dig up samples.
>> Why is this? Am I asking for something non-standard or unreasonable? Are
>> writing samples usually brought only to the interview? If so, how the heck
>> can you tell in advance if the person is worth interviewing?
>This is a wonderful question. I have a huge, widely-varied portfolio,
>and I have trouble providing writing samples for these reasons:
>* I frequently work under nondisclosure agreements that prevent me
>from sharing or even discussing the projects. I have had a client for
>10 years that is so sensitive about confidentiality that I cannot
>even include them on my resume. Some clients, understanding that we
>contractors need to show our past work, will stipulate that we can
>show the publication in an interview but not leave it unattended.
>* I negotiate for a portfolio copy when I start a writing project.
>This means that I have only one copy of what you want to look at.
>Such a sample might not be valuable, but it's irreplaceable. I'm
>not going to leave this treasure anywhere because people don't
>return writing samples no matter what they promise. I actually
>have holes in my portfolio because I supplied writing samples that
>* A potential client often is not clear about the type of project
>to be done. Is it a reference manual? A set of job aids? I'm surprised
>at how many people are uncomfortable discussing the project over the
>phone and "would prefer to discuss this with you in detail when you
>come for the interview." Such reluctance means that I might not
>bring an appropriate writing sample with me.
>* I like to discuss my samples as the potential client looks at them.
>I relate the pleasures and aggravations of the project, to what extent
>the project was a collaboration, any special problems I solved, how
>the deadline was, etc.
>* Even though I like to look at writing samples, I have been suspicious
>of them ever since I saw a woman take all the leftover unclaimed
>at an STC Publications Competition award banquet several years ago.
>* Sometimes I can't tell exactly what you (the generic "you"--the
>client) want to find when you look at a sample. Do you want to see the
>recent job? The biggest book? The most challenging PageMaker job I have
>done? The book with the statistical equations? Are you going to look at
>book I wrote 18-months ago and say "Do you have something more recent?"
>Does the job have to be 100% mine or can I show you a team effort? If a
>book has a lot of artistic graphics and spot color, are you going to
>it better because it's prettier?
>> Does anybody have some hot tips on how to tell if an
>> applicant has such high-level [PageMaker} skills?
>Why don't you just ask the applicant? If you explain how tough the
>is going to be and that training is not provided, the applicants can